The phrase 'cold calling' means two quite different things. In sales, it describes contacting a prospect who has not asked to hear from you. In education, it describes a teacher calling on a student who has not raised their hand. This article is mainly about the second meaning: what cold calling in the classroom is, where it comes from, what the research says about its effects, and how teachers can use it well. Because we work with sales teams every day, we also look at what the classroom version can teach anyone who picks up the phone to a buyer. The two practices share more than a name, and the overlap is genuinely useful.
What cold calling in the classroom means
In a classroom, cold calling simply means the teacher chooses who answers a question, rather than waiting for volunteers. Instead of asking 'Who can tell me?' and picking from the raised hands, the teacher asks the question, pauses, and then names a student. The student may or may not have expected to be asked, which is where the term 'cold' comes from.
The technique is used at every level of education, from primary schools to university business programmes. Its purpose is to make every student responsible for thinking about every question, not just the confident few who tend to volunteer. If anyone might be asked, everyone has a reason to prepare an answer in their head.
Cold calling is often contrasted with 'hands up' questioning, where only volunteers answer. Hands up questioning is simple and feels safe, but it allows many students to stay silent for an entire lesson. Over time, the same handful of students do most of the talking, and the teacher gets a misleading picture of how well the class as a whole has understood the material.
There are many variations. Some teachers cold call after giving everyone time to discuss in pairs. Some ask the question first and name the student second, so that everyone thinks before knowing who will answer. Others use random selection, such as names drawn from a pot. All share the same idea: participation is expected, not optional.
Where the technique comes from
Cold calling has a long history in professional education, particularly in law and business schools. The case method, in which students analyse real business situations and debate what the decision maker should do, depends on active discussion. If only volunteers spoke, many students would prepare less and learn less.
Harvard Business School is the best-known example. Its library's exhibition on teaching and the case method describes how professors often open a class, after a brief introduction, by calling on a student at random. The exhibition presents this cold call as a chance for the student to state a point of view, answer hard questions in real time and contribute to the group's learning.
The same material describes how much preparation the method demands from teachers. Instructors plan questions in advance, use seating charts with students' names and faces, and manage the discussion closely. The cold call is not a random ambush. It is one part of a carefully designed conversation in which the teacher knows what they want each stage of the discussion to achieve.
From these professional schools, cold calling spread into undergraduate teaching and, in various forms, into school classrooms. Today it appears in teacher training programmes and classroom guides, often alongside techniques such as giving students thinking time and asking them to discuss in pairs before answering.
What the research says about participation
A common objection to cold calling is that it makes students anxious and less willing to speak. If students fear being put on the spot, the argument goes, they will withdraw. Researchers at Northeastern University set out to test that assumption in management education, with results that surprised many teachers.
Elise Dallimore, Julie Hertenstein and Marjorie Platt published a study on the impact of cold-calling on student voluntary participation in the Journal of Management Education. As a summary of their work notes, conventional wisdom held that cold calling makes students clam up. The researchers found otherwise. According to a later review of the research by Learning and the Brain, the study found that cold calling increased voluntary participation and reduced discomfort among the students studied.
The finding matters because it challenges the idea that cold calling and voluntary participation are opposites. In the classes studied, students who were cold called more often also became more willing to volunteer. One plausible explanation is practice: students who regularly speak in class become more comfortable doing so, and that comfort carries over into choosing to speak.
This does not mean cold calling always works or that it suits every student. The research was conducted in particular settings, mostly with university students in business courses. But it does suggest that the most common fear about cold calling, that it will shut students down, is not automatically justified.
Cold calling and gender equity
A second question is whether cold calling affects different groups of students differently. Research over many years has found that women often participate less than men in some classroom discussions and report less comfort with speaking. If cold calling helped men more than women, it could widen that gap.
The same research team examined this in a 2019 study, Leveling the Playing Field: How Cold-Calling Affects Class Discussion Gender Equity, published in the Journal of Education and Learning. They found that cold calling increased voluntary participation for both men and women. In classes with high levels of cold calling, women volunteered as many answers as men, while in classes with little cold calling, women answered fewer questions than men.
The figures reported in the Learning and the Brain review are striking. In high cold-calling classes, the share of women who voluntarily participated rose to 82 per cent, compared with 52 per cent in low cold-calling classes. For men, the equivalent figures were 73 per cent and 57 per cent. In other words, women's participation increased more than men's.
Neither group reported more discomfort as a result of being cold called. The authors concluded that cold calling may help both men and women perform better in class discussions and may make classrooms more equitable. For teachers concerned that only the most confident students dominate discussion, this is a useful finding.
The limits of the evidence
It is important not to overstate what these studies show. The Learning Scientists, in their summary of the cold calling research, point out that the 2019 study was correlational. Students and instructors were not randomly assigned to high or low cold-calling classes, so the study cannot prove that cold calling caused the changes in participation.
There were other limitations. The study observed a limited number of class sessions in one undergraduate accounting course, and gender was recorded in different ways at different points. These are normal constraints in classroom research, but they mean the findings should be treated as encouraging rather than conclusive.
Context also matters. Most of the research comes from university business and accounting courses in the United States. School pupils, students with particular anxieties or learning needs, and classrooms in other cultures may respond differently. A technique that works well in a seminar of motivated adults may need adapting for a class of twelve-year-olds.
The honest conclusion is that the available evidence does not support the idea that cold calling is inherently harmful, and it suggests some real benefits for participation and equity. More rigorous experiments would help. In the meantime, how the technique is used probably matters as much as whether it is used at all.
Cold calling and retrieval practice
Cold calling also connects to one of the most studied ideas in learning science: retrieval practice. When students try to recall information from memory, rather than simply rereading it, they tend to remember it better later. Questions in class, if everyone tries to answer them, are a form of retrieval practice.
The Learning Scientists discuss work by Megan Sumeracki and Johanny Castillo on covert and overt retrieval practice, published in Translational Issues in Psychological Science. Covert retrieval means thinking of an answer in your head. Cold calling encourages covert retrieval across the whole class, because any student might be asked to say their answer aloud.
The same work notes a limitation. Covert retrieval is hard to get students to do consistently, and some research suggests students may overestimate how well they are learning when they only answer in their heads. Where there is time, asking students to write their answers down first, which is overt retrieval, is likely to be more effective.
In practice, many teachers combine the two. They ask a question, give everyone time to write a brief answer or discuss it with a partner, and then cold call a few students to share. This approach gives every student a chance to retrieve the answer, reduces the pressure of being put on the spot, and still keeps the whole class accountable.
How to cold call well in a classroom
Teachers who use cold calling effectively tend to follow a few consistent principles. The first is predictability. If students know that cold calling is a normal part of every lesson, it feels routine rather than threatening. Explaining the purpose at the start of a course, and doing it regularly, removes much of the anxiety.
The second is to ask the question before naming the student. 'What do you think caused this, Sarah?' gives everyone except Sarah permission to stop thinking. 'What do you think caused this? Sarah?' makes the whole class think first. A short pause between question and name, often called wait time, gives students a moment to form an answer.
The third is to make success likely. Good teachers start with questions most students can answer, build up to harder ones, and allow students to discuss in pairs first. If a student struggles, the teacher can rephrase, offer a clue or come back to them later, rather than leaving them exposed. The aim is to build confidence, not to catch people out.
The fourth is warmth. Tone matters enormously. A cold call delivered with genuine interest in the student's thinking feels very different from one delivered as a test. Thanking students for answers, building on what they say and treating mistakes as useful material all make students more willing to engage next time.
It also helps to vary the format. Not every cold call needs to be a single student answering in front of everyone. A teacher might cold call a pair to report back on their discussion, ask a student to build on a classmate's answer, or invite someone to say which of two views they find more convincing. Variety keeps the routine fresh and gives students different ways to contribute, which is particularly useful for those who find speaking alone in front of the class difficult.
Common mistakes teachers make
One common mistake is using cold calling as a disciplinary tool. Calling on a student because they appear distracted, in the hope of embarrassing them, turns a learning technique into a punishment. Students quickly learn to associate being called on with being in trouble, which undermines the whole approach.
Another mistake is calling on the same students repeatedly, or avoiding certain students altogether. Teachers may unconsciously avoid quieter students or those they expect to struggle. Simple systems, such as tracking who has been asked or drawing names at random, help to spread questions fairly across the class.
A third mistake is asking questions that are too hard or too vague. 'Any thoughts?' is difficult to answer when called on cold. A specific, well-framed question gives students something concrete to respond to. Questions should be challenging enough to require thought but clear enough that a prepared student can make a reasonable attempt.
Finally, some teachers abandon the technique after a few awkward lessons. Like any routine, cold calling takes time to become comfortable for both teacher and students. Persisting for several weeks, while explaining the purpose and keeping the tone supportive, usually produces a noticeable change in how willing the class is to participate.
Same phrase, different meaning: cold calling in sales
In sales, cold calling means phoning a potential customer who has not asked to be contacted. It remains one of the most direct ways for B2B companies to start conversations with new accounts, particularly when buyers are hard to reach by email. Our guide to cold calling strategies covers the practical side in detail.
The two meanings developed separately, but they share a core idea. In both cases, one person starts a conversation with someone who did not volunteer for it. In both cases, the person being called may feel put on the spot, and the success of the exchange depends heavily on how the caller prepares and behaves.
Sales cold calling has a mixed reputation for many of the same reasons classroom cold calling does. Done badly, it feels intrusive and stressful. Done well, it can open useful conversations that would never have happened otherwise. The difference, in both settings, comes down to preparation, relevance and respect for the other person.
That shared foundation means the classroom research and teaching practice offer genuinely useful lessons for sales teams. The next sections look at what transfers from one setting to the other, and also where the comparison breaks down.
Lessons sales teams can take from the classroom
The first lesson is preparation. A case-method professor plans each question and knows what a good answer looks like. A good sales caller does the same: they research the account, understand the person's role and plan specific questions. A call that opens with a relevant observation about the prospect's business feels very different from one that opens with a generic pitch.
The second lesson is to make the first answer easy. Teachers start with questions students can answer before moving to harder ones. In a sales call, opening with a simple, relevant question about the prospect's situation gives them a comfortable way into the conversation. Asking them to commit to a meeting in the first thirty seconds is the equivalent of asking the hardest question first.
The third lesson is tone. Students respond better to cold calls delivered with genuine curiosity, and buyers do too. A caller who is interested in the prospect's challenges, listens carefully and responds to what they say builds trust. A caller reading a script at speed does not.
The fourth lesson is consistency. Classroom cold calling works better when it is a predictable routine. In sales, consistent daily calling, with careful notes and steady follow-up, produces better results than occasional bursts. Our cold calling teams work to this kind of steady rhythm, combined with careful research on every account.
The fifth lesson is to treat a weak answer as information rather than failure. A good teacher who receives a confused answer learns something about what the class has not yet understood. A sales caller who hears 'we already have a supplier' or 'not this year' has learned something about the account's situation and timing. Recording that properly, and using it to plan the next contact, turns an apparently unsuccessful call into a useful step. Teams that book meetings from these later conversations often find our appointment setting approach helpful for keeping that follow-up consistent.
Where the comparison breaks down
There is one important difference between the two settings. Students have enrolled in a course and accepted that participation is part of it. A prospect receiving a sales call has made no such agreement. That difference means sales cold calling carries obligations that classroom questioning does not.
In the United Kingdom, the ICO's guidance on business-to-business marketing sets out rules for live marketing calls to businesses. Callers should not call numbers registered with the TPS or CTPS unless the business has consented, must not call businesses that have previously objected, and must identify their organisation. Screening against these registers and your own do-not-call list is expected before calling.
Other countries have their own rules for calls and electronic marketing. In France, for example, the CNIL's guidance on electronic communications to prospects requires B2B messages to relate to the recipient's professional activity and to offer a simple way to object. Sales teams working across Europe need to check the rules in each country before starting outreach.
A good classroom cold call also assumes the teacher will come back to the student next week. Sales calls should be made with the same long-term view. A respectful call that ends politely, even without a meeting, leaves the door open. A pushy call that ignores a clear 'no' damages both the relationship and the company's reputation.
Buyers are a class, not a single student
One more classroom lesson applies directly to B2B sales. A teacher's goal is for the whole class to learn, not just the student who happens to be called on. Similarly, in B2B sales, the goal is to bring a whole buying group to a decision, not just to win over one contact.
Gartner's research on the B2B buying journey describes a typical buying group for a complex solution as involving six to ten decision makers. Gartner also found that buyers spend only 17 per cent of their purchase consideration time meeting with potential suppliers. A single call to a single person, however good, is a small part of a much larger process.
This is why many B2B teams now combine cold calling with other channels. A call may introduce the conversation, but LinkedIn outreach, researched email and account-based marketing help reach the rest of the buying group. Meeting people in person, at events or on site visits, often builds the trust needed to move a decision forward.
For companies entering a new market, this matters even more. Buyers who have never heard of you need several reasons to take you seriously. Local on-ground sales reps who can follow a good call with a face-to-face meeting give a newcomer the same advantage a well-prepared teacher has: the chance to build a relationship over time, not just in a single exchange.
Bringing it together
Cold calling in the classroom is a simple technique with a surprisingly strong evidence base. Research in university business education suggests it can increase voluntary participation, does not appear to increase discomfort and may reduce gender gaps in class discussion. The evidence has limits, but it is more encouraging than many teachers expect.
The technique works best when it is predictable, well prepared and warm. Teachers who ask the question before naming a student, allow thinking time, start with accessible questions and treat answers with respect tend to get the most from it. Those who use it to embarrass or catch out students usually get the opposite result.
Sales teams can learn from the same principles. Preparation, relevance, a comfortable opening, genuine curiosity and consistency all make sales cold calls more effective and more respectful. The key difference is consent: sales callers must follow the rules on who they can contact and must honour objections.
Whether you are a teacher planning tomorrow's lesson or a sales leader planning next quarter's outreach, the underlying lesson is the same. People respond better to being asked when they can see that the person asking has prepared, is genuinely interested in their answer and will treat them fairly.